Who Is Really Killing American Democracy?



By a vote of 30-1 in the House, with unanimous support in the Senate, Juneteenth, June 19, which commemorates the day in 1865 when news of Abraham Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation reached Texas, has been declared a federal holiday.

It is to be called Juneteenth Independence Day.

Prediction: This will become yet another source of societal division as many Black folks celebrate their special Independence Day, and the rest of America continues to celebrate July 4 as Independence Day two weeks later.

Why the pessimism? Consider.

Days before Congress acted, the Randolph, New Jersey, board of education voted to change Columbus Day to Indigenous Peoples Day. A backlash ensued, and the board quickly voted to rescind its decision.

Still under fire, the board voted to drop all designated holidays from the school calendar and replace them with the simple notation “Day Off.”

The school board had surrendered, punted, given up on trying to find holidays that the citizens of Randolph might celebrate together.

But the “day off” mandate created another firestorm, and the board is now restoring all the previous holidays, including that of Columbus.

The point: If we Americans cannot even agree on which heroes and holidays are to be celebrated together, does that not tell us something about whether we are really, any longer, one country and one people?

Do we still meet in any way the designation and description of us as the “one united people” that John Jay rendered in The Federalist Papers:

“Providence has been pleased to give this one connected country to one united people — a people descended from the same ancestors, speaking the same language, professing the same religion, attached to the same principles of government, very similar in their manners and customs.”

Does that depiction remotely resemble America in 2021?

Today, we don’t even agree on whether Providence exists.

We hear constant worries these days about a clear and present danger to “our democracy” itself. And if democracy requires, as a precondition, a community, a commonality, of religious, cultural, social and moral beliefs, we have to ask whether these necessary ingredients of a democracy still exist in 21st-century America.

Consider what has happened to the holidays that united Americans of the Greatest and Silent Generations.

Christmas and Easter, the great Christian Holy Days and holidays of that era, were expunged a half-century ago from the public schools and the public square — replaced by winter break and spring break.

The Bible, the cross and the Ten Commandments were all expelled as contradicting the secularist commands of our Constitution.

Traditional Christian teachings about homosexuality and abortion, reflected in public law, are now regarded as hallmarks of homophobia, bigotry, sexism and misogyny -- i.e., of moral and mental sickness.

Not only do Americans' views on religion and morality collide, but we also seem ever more rancorously divided now on matters of history and race.

Was Christopher Columbus a heroic navigator and explorer who "discovered" America -- or a genocidal racist? Was the colonization of America a great leap forward for civilization and mankind, or the monstrous crime of technically superior European peoples who came to brutally impose their religion, race and rule upon indigenous peoples?

Three of the six Founding Fathers and most of the presidents of the first 60 years of our republic were slave owners: George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, James Monroe, Andrew Jackson, John Tyler, James Polk and Zachary Taylor, as well as the legendary senators Henry Clay and John Calhoun.

A number of Americans now believe that Washington and Jefferson should be dynamited off Mount Rushmore at the same time the visages of the three great Confederates -- Gen. Robert E. Lee, Gen. Stonewall Jackson and Confederate President Jefferson Davis -- are dynamited off Stone Mountain, Georgia.

From all this comes a fundamental question.

Is the left itself -- as its cultural and racial revolution dethrones the icons of America's past, who are still cherished by a majority -- irreparably fracturing that national community upon which depends the survival of the democracy they profess to cherish?

Are they themselves imperiling the political system at whose altar they worship?

The country is not the polity. The nation is not the state. Force Americans to choose between the claims of God, faith, family, tribe and country -- and the demands of democracy -- and you may not like the outcome.

A question needs to be put to the left in America.

If your adversaries in politics are indeed fascists, racists, sexists, homophobes, xenophobes and bigots, as you describe them, why would, or should, such people accept and embrace your rule over them -- simply because you managed to rack up a plurality of ballots in an election?

Free elections to decide who governs are, it is said, the central sacrament of democracy. But why should people who are described with every synonym for "deplorable" not reject the politics of compromise and instead work constantly to overthrow the rule of people who so detest them?

Winston Churchill called democracy "the worst form of government except all those other forms that have been tried."

Are both sides sticking with democracy -- for lack of an alternative?

When you sign up to comment you'll also receive our regular newsletter. You can find more about how we use your information here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

5 thoughts on “Who Is Really Killing American Democracy?”

  1. This essay is outstanding in its endeavor to explore the depth, breadth, and motion of this most important question: Who is killing American democracy? What I find intriguing, is the fact that everyone—all Americans—already know the answer to this question, they already know that what is happening is wrong, is vile, is disingenuous, is a dishonor to so many who sacrificed, but so many of these individuals go along with the disintegration of the foundation beneath their very feet. It matters not if it is by curiosity, peer pressure, or apathy, they are complicit with fanning the flames that burn their own house. The answer that is coming if nothing is done to thwart it will be one of irreversible subjugation of the masses, irretrievable freedoms, and smothering governance that puts the lights out, permanently.

  2. You missed another example of what’s been going wrong. When it was decided to make Martin Luther Kings birthday a national holiday, the “tradeoff” was eliminating Washington’s and Lincoln’s (arguably our two greatest presidents) not just merging the two into one but labeling the anonymous “Presidents’ Day” so that All Presidents are included and no more holidays will be named for individuals. Sorry but, not caring if I’m not PC I don’t consider King the Greatest man in American history. Now we have a new National Independence Day (named significant to “honor” a small minority within a minority). Does anyone else see a pattern here?

  3. This is insanity! The only reason Juneteenth ever came up for public discussion was because Trump had planned to have a rally in Texas on that day, so the Leftist dirt-rakers looking for some reason to scuttle the rally hit upon a VERY Texas-only celebration and claimed it was a national thing, WHEN IT NEVER WAS, that’s why no one outside of Texas had ever heard of it before the MSM took it and ran with it a few years ago.

    Texas wasn’t even the last state to free its slaves, since it freed them only a little over a month after the Civil War ended on May 9, 1865, so why does our Texas-specific singular day wind up a national thing? It seems the date the LAST state set their slaves free should be a better choice. The Thirteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution abolished slavery throughout the United States on December 6, 1865, that’s a better day than Juneteenth, since it’s truly a national day.

    However, quoting from: Where in the U.S. did slavery still exist after Juneteenth? http://www.tracingcenter.org/blog/2016/06/where-in-the-u-s-did-slavery-still-exist-after-juneteenth/

    “Delaware wouldn’t ratify the 13th Amendment, thus acquiescing in the end of slavery, until 1901. Kentucky resisted the 13th Amendment until 1976.”

    Those are the most glaring, but there were other states as well.